I think the 2nd one if you did more with it. It looks like you're trying to sort of parody dopeys avatar in the second one, you should give the star like a bevel/emboss to make it look more like dopeys then it would be the best in my opinion.
The following user thanked MATT23116 for this useful post:
I think the 2nd one if you did more with it. It looks like you're trying to sort of parody dopeys avatar in the second one, you should give the star like a bevel/emboss to make it look more like dopeys then it would be the best in my opinion.
I don't know what you use, but in photoshop there's a bevel/emboss feature, that makes it look shiny and stand out. it would make it look more like dopeys, because your star right now seems sort of plain.