Originally posted by joshblake8808
cinema 4d r11.5 is much better than r12 because you get much more mo graph things
12 is actually better than 11.5 - They just changed the way Mograph and physics works.
Originally posted by xDarkstar
There pretty much the same, just different interfaces, i used 3Ds Max for quite a while but then changed to C4D. It offers pretty much the same things but i feel C4D has the advantage with having more tutorials around the internet as well as in my opinion the ability to have better lighting rigs, with plugins such as the HDRI light kit pro from Grey Scale Gorilla which also saves a bunch of time.
The HDRI light kit was a light kit for cinema 4d used to make lighting scenes like the DEFAULT scenes in 3ds max. The lighting is good, sure, but I believe the lighting in 3DS is better due to a MUCH larger variety of options.