Well you are correct in some ways gentlemen... But
The Xbox is a far superior system.
Graphics for instance, all Xbox games are shipped at 1080p. Tell me how Sony ships many games in 720p when they are rocking a blue ray drive?
The answer you ask...?
Lack of utilized power within the PS3, further more the blue ray drive does not I repeat does not make a game have better graphics all it is a storage medium for the information that the counsel uses to play your game.
Solution for Xbox installing game information on your hard drive. Of course you have to wait to install it but no biggie its worth the wait.
As for the Kinect goes I myself am not a Kinect used but it is clearly superior to the ps Move in every way possible (can you straight Minority Report your way through your music and movie files?)
The controller...
I have man hands and the Wife has Lady hands... We can both play Xbox.
I on the other hand am afraid to press play on the blue ray player for fear that it will implode on itself. They are so fragile, I mean come on its not a piece of glass, its a controller if I drop it or it falls off the couch I don't want to have to replace it every time I sneeze.
Finally
Xbox live Vs. PSN
Xbox live would be like if Tyson fought a baby. Hands down no comparison, but I will anyway.
Sure you have to pay for Xbox live... Blah Blah Blah
Servers are better
Network is better
Apps are better
Updates are better
Games are better
DLC/extras are better
The list goes on and on
PSN's network was hacked in minutes, Credit card #'s stolen, network down for months at a time.
No Eff that I will pay the little extra to have more fun.
In the end its just about who is educated and willing to accept fact for what they are...
FACTS.
I own a PS3 and love it but if you just compare them the PS3 has one thing the blue ray play and that is exactly why I purchased it.