Originally posted by Just4Hax
True, but to those who attempt to live off a more "justice", this seems insane and "immoral"
I will happily admit, the emotional side of me is upset by the idea. If someone had raped, maimed or killed a member of my family for example, I'd want them tortured and killed in a gruesome way because I'd want vengence. It would seem ultimately unfair to let that person have anything ever again after what they took away.... however entirely rational me has to be rational.
If we're honest, after about 10 years, no-one is the same as they where. The "me" from 10 years ago is a very different person than the "me" of today. Do I think this is the same for prisoners, sure. With proper re-education programs, logically speaking I do agree that someone who went into a prison as a raging psycho could come out a productive member of society and if you look at the crime statistics in Norway... well they do. Now, do I have an emotional objection? Yes. But it's because I'm wanting vengence, not justice.
If we look at statistics across Europe and USA you'll see that the more severe a prison sentence and the less focused on reabilitation the prison system is, the higher the crime rate. Hell, the crime rate is the highest in states such as Louisiana and Texas yet they have the death penalty. So it doesn't work as a deterrent either.
From a more utilitarian point of view as well, having lower prison sentences and a system where less crime in commit for whatever reason, means the prison system costs less tax to run, so in that respect it's fairer for the Norwiegian people.