Originally posted by xinfectedsoulx
I understand what you mean about leaving, but how do you think the soldiers and the families of soldiers who have died would feel? They would have died for an unsuccessful mission. Watching many documentaries, a lot of the soldiers from the British army don't want to just leave with a failed mission because there are many deaths and injuries that would have been caused for no reason. What's point in all the deaths if you don't finish the job?
I agree with the fact that America or Britain have no right in trying to bring our way of living to other countries. If they want to change, they'll change. We can't keep using force to make them change. America did go in over confident thinking it wouldn't take long and all NATO went in the wrong way about it. Dropping bombs left right and centre is going to make more people join the Taliban. That wasn't helping, destroying houses and towns. Now though you can see a change with how they have to deal with them. Positively ID'ing them with weapons before shooting. That way they avoid as much as possible innocent lives being taken. If they did that from the start, maybe the war would almost be at an end.
Just stopping all Aid isn't a good move. America is one of the richest countries in the world. It's not Africas fault they are poor. They need help. Sure, our countries should look after their own people first, but spending money left and and centre isn't the way to go about it. Millions of money will be put into things that aren't needed, but giving some money to aid is needed.
We should declare Victory and pull out. No hard feelings then, mission accomplished. Just like we did with Iraq. The goal here is to establish an Afghan Army so they can defend their own lands. I feel that if we establish a date for withdraw, say 01/01/2013, then the Afghan Army would really step it up. We've been trying to train them for a couple years now. But, the case for them is "Let's just let the Americans go find the bombs." Well, the Americans are leaving and you better be ready by 01/01/2013.
Those countries have lived the way they do for thousands of years. Who are we to "westernize" them? They for sure don't want it, they just want protection from the Taliban. Which is why their army needs to step up. All innocent lives should be spared in times of war. It's not right to attempt to protect somebody, but take your protectee's lives and homes as collateral damage. If you invade lands, it's best to have the people on your side. Like you said, blowing up their town just makes them spite you. They have more motive to fight back.
By all aid, I meant all aid to hostile nations. We give so much money to countries who would slit our throats if they had the chance. America's money keeps the UN, the IMF, and the World Bank running. They would have barely any authority or influence, or even ability if they were cut out of the budget. It's a nominal number, really, $5 billion to "charity" is nothing when you spend $700 billion of defense. I think we need to pick and choose who gets the money. Why are we giving money to Pakistan? They hate us! That's like going to a fight and giving your foe your knife. I do agree that countries like Jordan, Kenya, etc. do in fact need aid.
---------- Post added at 02:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:56 PM ----------
Originally posted by ClutchLikeBenny
Why are you being so racist? America shouldn't have gone in the first place, because America is WAAY over confident. And your arguement about them not speaking "your language" is completely invalid because the Arabs are probably saying the same about you, and you should support trade with them because they have more money per capita then any other country in world in my opinion. Ron Paul and the Republicans are completely stupid. Obama has been trying to get troops out but you can't just drop the guns and leave, it's a very slow process.
Sorry for being pissed of that good people are dying in some shithole in the middle east! They lost their lives protecting me, all Americans. They are trying to save the people of Afghanistan! I have every right to hate the people killing fellow Americans and attempting to kill their own people.
America has every reason to be there. Terrorists sent Anthrax to Senators and federal buildings in Washington D.C. (I work in D.C.) Terrorists killed regular people on planes and in the Pentagon (Also in D.C.) and World Trade Centers. They also plotted to hit the White House (Again, in D.C.) but it was foiled by the valiant passengers. ATTACKS ON AMERICANS AND ON AMERICAN SOIL WILL NOT GO UNPUNISHED!
Trade with them? I think you're delusional. Afghanistan has a GDP of $11 billion and a per capita of $900 DOLLARS. I make $900 in a couple days. They take a year! I support trade with nations like Saudi Arabia and the U.A.E., but they are allies, not terrorists. No shit I support trade.
What about them speaking our language? Afghanistan has a 28% literacy rate OF THEIR OWN LANGUAGE!
Obama is a socialist. He's raising the debt ceiling by a trillion dollars whenever he can to continue to socialize every aspect of America. SMALL GOVERNMENT! SMALL GOVERNMENT! If Ron Paul wins the nation will be fixed.