It all comes down to the control pads folkes, I prefer the dualshock 3 (DS3) of a ps3 its perfect, everything is where it should be, xbox 360 gamepad doesn't float my boat, sticks are wonky, and that battery pack gets on my tits. if someone could weigh their xbox pad and post the results that would be great( in grams please i'm using the metric system). The xbox pad has more girth, just feels too bulky while the DS3 fits snuggly in my clasping hands. also the d-pad is better.
To sum it up i like my control pads like my women, elegant and classy, not fat and chunky.
PS3 all the way.