i reckon the 1st because, i love the compostion, effects and general layout of it, light source also works 100% with the render, text is a bit bold but i think it works, i would have moved everything to the right more to have the text central but theres no problem with the layout you chose. others may down the bold text. but purples and blues are my fav colours to work with if not with a green aswell, so i really like this one
the 2nd is not for me but i think most ppl will chose this on skill it looks more flawless than the 1st and will probs do better, now i've probaly confused u so...
enter 2nd FTW, but i like version 1 better personally