Originally posted by soccerdude84
yeah, i tried playing story mode to see if one of the trophy with the no continues would pop, and then after the first level i somehow earned a trophy i already earned 2 years ago
i was like "wtf is this", then i looked at my trophy list and saw shatter at 4%, when it was previously 80%
i had a mini-heart attack
this happens when you havent synched trophies - if you resync it wont happen.
i know as my brother couldnt do the movelist on wwe smackdown vs raw 2010, he had one move he couldnt do, so i logged in my end and did it. unfortunately i hadnt synched, so it only popped one trophy and not the plat. then i synched and it came up as the plat - but i didnt get to see the plat pop.
it also happens if you havent played a game on that console, but did on a previous one or you put a newer hdd in the meantime.