(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Mine would definitely have to be Silent Hill 2. I remember playing it alone and in the dark with the speakers turned up just to get the full experience of the game lol.
The part when your stuck in the room with Pyramid head nearly made me shit myself LOL Silent Hill: Home coming was ok, but didn't scare me quite as much as part 2. Also enjoyed Project Zero (Fatal frame) was an alternative style to the usual survivor horror franchise, gave me a shit load of frights lol.

dead rising 2

super mario 64. i nearly shat my pants when i saw that goomba charging full speed at me. oh and dont forget that monkey can just swoop down and mug ur hat

slient hill is scary lol