Originally posted by Kaspa
Although I agree with the majority of your points you have made, we need to consider the fact that chronic depression is an illness, it effects the way one thinks and or values themselves and how people see them. I don't agree with suicide, I'm fully against it due to the same reasons you have stated.
When I went through chronic depression, suicide was always on my mind, it's only until after you surpass the depression you look back and think 'Shit, I almost killed myself'. During the depression you can't stop thinking about it, you think everyone hates you and you have no bright future, you're reminded every second to what happened, and suicide is always on your mind, trust me it's really hard.
It was only with the help of my family that I was able to move forward from the troublesome events that took place, but without my families support, I'm pretty sure there was a high possibility that I would have ended my life.
I think it's easier to understand if you put it this way, right now if I was to think of killing myself I would feel sick and frankly couldn't see it ever taking place, because I value life importantly. But during the period that I was depressed, it was almost as if I really wanted to do it, like it was the only way out, you know?
It's a hard thing to discuss and even try to explain, but I hope you get where I'm coming from.
Oh, I understand that. I have suffered bouts of depression at times myself where I can think of little else other that how I have nothing of value to look forward to and how everything is shit... but I've never really been suicidal. The only times I've had suicidal thoughts are during migraines, when I'm at the height of pain, in full seizure. At that point I distinctly remember multiple times where I've wished I could die just to make the pain go away, but at those times I'm delirious and overcome by pain.
I think it's just that I have trouble imagining the level of trauma someone would have to go though to push them that far. I have trouble relating. All in all I'm more trying to put a counter-point to an issue where most people focus on the bullying and not this trend in modern times of kids throwing themselves of bridges like f*cking lemmings. 30 years ago, child suicide rates where considerably lower, and honestly, while the bullying does need to be addressed, we're in a more liberal and compassionate society now more than ever so why are suicides increasing. The kids need to toughen up because as much as we may not like it, the world isn't fair. That's, I feel, the point I'm trying to make.
Perhaps I'm not the best person to consider psychological or mental pain. I have to deal with physical pain on a daily basis, my view is most certainly skewed.
---------- Post added at 04:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:09 AM ----------
You know there is a lot to read here and a lot of different opinions. This is the beauty of living in countries of freedom is that everyone can have their own opinion. I know of 2 people I went to school with that have taken their own lives. As a lot of people look at it an an "easy way out" you really have to stop and consider what people are feeling when they do this act.
I feel bad for everyone in this situation. I mean you have people that is morning the lose of a child, nephew, grandchild, friend, etc. As a society we are quick to look at the bully and put 100% blame on them. Not saying they didn't contribute a lot to the situation. It's the lack of resources set place by our ministries. If the child being bullied had someone more accessible to them then this could have been prevented. But the same goes for the bullies as well. We all need someone to talk to. Bottom line is that nobody knows what goes on in someone else's head or what kind of abusive life they live. Usually when people bully it's because they themselves get bullied and they look for someone "weaker" then they are to bully. Then that person in turn bullies someone else and so on. A lot of people here at NGU are lucky they have the family or friends to talk to if things are bothering them. Just imagine if you had nobody to turn to. I feel really bad for this young kid that took their own life but I also feel bad for the bully because they need help as well.
Just remember that when you hear about something like this you have to look at both sides. We need to help one another and intervene when necessary. Because if we in turn make comments at the bullies we become bullies ourselves. We can't wait until it's too late to help because if we do this happens.
Interesting position. I'm not sure I'm as sympathetic to the bully's need as you. While some do have emotional issues that lead them to bullying others are simply bad people who delight in hurting others. Some people are nice, and others are not, it's a sad realisation but not every person who acts with cruelty or malice do so because of trauma or issues, some are just horrible people.
All in all, I'm not sure the "someone to talk to" method is working. I feel we're softening our children too much in the most recent generations. People are so quick to say the kids need councilors and people to confide in that I feel it's making it more and more a reality that children cannot rely on themselves. People are losing the ability to be retrospective, to work thought their own emotional problems, because they're taught from a young age that they should "ask for help" and that they shouldn't be afraid to talk about their emotions and I wonder if, while good intentions are there, this method isn't removing all sense of willpower from these kids and effectively brainwashing them into feeling powerless without a psychiatrist at hand to explain which traumatic event made them feel angry today... but that's just my opinion, I have nothing to back it up with.