I like how we are actually having a discussion where the US and Russia would go to war, even though both nations are involved with the UN and whoever struck first would be met with backlash. Let's be honest, this war is unlikely to happen as of right now as the focus is currently on the Middle East and nations such as Syria.
Now, if somehow a war did breakout between Russia and the US, the US would undoubtedly become victorious. Those who are talking about nuclear war have no clue what they're even saying. Neither nation would let it go nuclear as that means they also lose. If you want an example take a look at Israel, which possesses nuclear arms, but doesn't use them against their enemies as it is simply impractical. Instead, a war would more likely result in several skirmishes, political warfare, and maybe some threats.
Once again, if it somehow did go nuclear, which is unlikely, then simply no one wins.
As a response to those talking about the Vietnam war, the reason we lost that was the fact there was little support for the troops and no moral. The war was being fought on weak grounds anyways. We basically were trying to suppress what the people were desiring based on our attack on communism.
---------- Post added at 12:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:15 PM ----------
Originally posted by Objectivate
You really think China would support the Americans?
Seeing as China would otherwise be going against one of the most powerful military in the world, and the trade between China and the US is worth over $450 billion, and it is estimated that the US owes china over $4 trillion it would be insane for them to attack us. If they did they can say goodbye to ever seeing that debt paid off, to trade, and instead say hello to a hellstorm that could only end in devastation (most likely to both sides).
It makes much more sense the would stay neutral, so they could instead profit from both sides of the war, but if they were forced to pick a side it would be the US as they could hold off Russia easily.
---------- Post added at 12:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:21 PM ----------
Originally posted by Objectivate
It wouldn't go nuclear. But if it was to, Russia would win. They have more, and they have bigger.
No one wins if anything goes nuclear today.
Originally posted by another user
If it was just a straight on fight between the two, without any support from alies, the winner would be determined by the ground it's fought on. Russia would win if America invaded Russia, and vice versa.
Here are some factors,
Military Budgets
Russia - about $56 billion (2010)
USA - about $683.7 billion (2010)
To break the US down for measure:
Army - $244.9 billion
Navy - $149.9 billion, excluding marine corps
Marine Corps - $170.6 billion
Estimated Defense Intelligence - $50 billion
Defense Wide Joint Activities - $118.7 billion
The US spends far more on its military than Russia ever could, in fact it is the highest spender as of date, with the next up being China estimated at $114 billion, over a $500 billion difference.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Personal
Russia - 1,027,000 active
USA - 1,477,896 active
The USA ranks 2nd in it's military personal. So not only does it have the technological hand, but pure man power as well. The only nation with more active would be China.
Without a doubt the US over powers Russia in almost every single way.
Originally posted by another user
Though, if you're not looking for an answer that includes location and just want to know who has the better army - probably America. But I suspect Russia would still win, due to their forces being tough as ****, and basically bad ass mother****ers - willing to die for their (most likely pointless) cause.
/facepalm Nothing points to Russia winning... at all
---------- Post added at 12:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:34 PM ----------
Look what the Russians done to the US in Modern Warfare 3.. Russia will win.
On a serious note, I say Russia will win because they are just all around an amazing army. Think about it, they have the largest Army with over 1 million personal
/facepalm Actually they rank fifth, with the US having over 400,000 more active personal
Originally posted by another user
one of the largest Navy's and Airforce in the world and the largest stockpile of Nuclear weapons.
Are we talking about the same Russia?
Russian Navy - 140,000 personnel
US Navy - 332,000 personnel
Russian Air force - 160,000 personnel
US Air Force - 323,000 personnel
As for nuclear weapons, no one wins if it goes nuclear.