Hmm, your sig is ok. My entry is nothing to jump up and down about it literally took 5 minutes but for your one I think it's too red, not necessarily monotone, just needs more variation in colours. Flow is ok but is messed up by the tree in the background if you understand what I mean. The text could use some work such as positioning and blending effect. Overall i'd give it a solid 6/10.

All criticism is there to merely better ones graphic abilities. If one does not constructively criticize ones work, one does not feel the need to better their skills. I know i'm not amazing, nor do I believe I am a graphics God, however I know some stuff when it comes to the subject, hence the reason I am in +cK. I do not understand the "Good job you can follow tutorials." part. Everyone at some stage or another follows tutorials... everyone. GFX'ers look to tutorials to learn new tricks and techniques to use in future sigs. I don't follow tutorials much anymore, but sometimes when I hit a little speed bump where I don't "feel" it, I tend to look at a tutorial or two until I get back in the groove. Other GFX'ers will understand what I mean. Now sir, do you understand? Happy holidays

Why is Groms so awesome? Everything is just amazing. If he doesn't win this time, someone must've rigged it :'(

Yeah, but lets take videobot for example. He is without doubt a graphics guru and has given me some of the best constructive criticism over the time I have been here. He produces very HQ fantastic work time after time. However, I don't understand why everyone is drooling over your work. Don't get me wrong i'm not hating or anything it's just that... It's a little.. i don't know, it's hard to explain.

Please don't take this the wrong way but this looks like a good beginners sig.
I'm not hating bro but I think a lot more could be done here.
I'm only pointing this out because it seems that everyone you made sigs for can't seem to hop off your dick and think you're a guru.
And if you're lied to you will never make the necessary adjustments to be that much better.
I'm no pro but I've been around LOL

yeah, you like simplicity, but there are better sigs in this competition atm, but by the look of it, every non-gfx user on this site is riding your cock.