Post: The Placebo Effect
11-25-2012, 01:47 AM #1
Mudkip
Retired Moderator
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Hello everyone,

now this is really a mix between a potential discussion and a question.

I am very keen when it comes to working out, I go to the gym 4 times a week and try to go for as long as possible. I recently started taking supplements and a friend of mine who is a personal trainer told me to start off with a supplement called CLA (Conjugated linoleic acid). It is a non-essential fatty burning acid which allows you to burn more calories for longer, aiding in fat loss and muscle growth. In short it is supposed to give you a lot of energy.

Now I'm almost at the end of my months cycle and I'm not noticing anything on a daily basis at the moment. When I first started taking them I felt like I was full of energy, but now I just feel normal. It has me questioning the supplement and considering if its a placebo effective drug.

here is a detailed summary of what the placebo effect is:

Originally posted by another user
That's the gist of the placebo effect. It's what happens when a person takes a medication that he or she perceives will help, although it actually has no proven therapeutic effect for his or her particular condition. The medicine or treatment itself is known as a placebo, from Latin for "I will please." There are a few different types of placebos. They may be pharmacologically inert, meaning that they contain no active ingredients. These types of placebos often contain basic ingredients like sugar (hence the term "sugar pill"). Medications that do have active ingredients but aren't proven to work on the patient's particular condition can also be placebos. There have even been placebos in the form of surgery, injections and other types of medical therapies. Some people believe that complementary and alternative medicine count as placebos, too.


a short sentence to sum it up: it's a fake drug that makes you think its "curing" you, but really it does nothing, and helps you get over what ever you're suffering, mentally.

Now the heart of the discussion is, do you think I'm under the placebo effect? Or is the drug actually working? Because there have been many positive results since I started, and I know many people that say this helped them very much when they wanted to achieve the same thing.
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
11-26-2012, 08:26 AM #11
Originally posted by LFC View Post
Hello everyone,

now this is really a mix between a potential discussion and a question.

I am very keen when it comes to working out, I go to the gym 4 times a week and try to go for as long as possible. I recently started taking supplements and a friend of mine who is a personal trainer told me to start off with a supplement called CLA (Conjugated linoleic acid). It is a non-essential fatty burning acid which allows you to burn more calories for longer, aiding in fat loss and muscle growth. In short it is supposed to give you a lot of energy.

Now I'm almost at the end of my months cycle and I'm not noticing anything on a daily basis at the moment. When I first started taking them I felt like I was full of energy, but now I just feel normal. It has me questioning the supplement and considering if its a placebo effective drug.

here is a detailed summary of what the placebo effect is:



a short sentence to sum it up: it's a fake drug that makes you think its "curing" you, but really it does nothing, and helps you get over what ever you're suffering, mentally.

Now the heart of the discussion is, do you think I'm under the placebo effect? Or is the drug actually working? Because there have been many positive results since I started, and I know many people that say this helped them very much when they wanted to achieve the same thing.


if you've been taking the product for a month & havent noticed changes, stop taking it...

i thought the ultimate placebo effect supplement was acai, but ive never heard what your taking...

whoever said supplements dont work take a look at a bodybuilder, you think they get like that on a healthy diet alone?

obviously you dont need supplements if you have a perfect diet with the correct intake of proteins, carbs, fat, vit, min etc, but you still wont see results as fast or great without supplements...

for you i'd recommend a diet protein shake, i hear phd belgian choc is good, maybe an all in one supplement for pre/post workout like synergy & creatine, either pills or flavourless powder, along with a healthy diet & working out, you will see results!!!

you should have 7 or more meals a day, on workout day the diet protein & pre/post workout count as 3 meals on rest days take protein twice & all in one once so it 3 meals still, you can swich the diet protein for mass gainer for carbs & fibre or have both & alternate & do high intensity training...

The following user thanked Xiao Xin for this useful post:

Mudkip
11-26-2012, 03:08 PM #12
Meatwad
Meatman
Originally posted by Konsumer View Post
I'm talking about muscle development. lolkid

Lolkid? Again I'm in college, so most certainly not a kid. And supplements like Creatine occur naturally in the body (because I'm assuming you eat meat) where you are already getting (for the most part) the maximum amount needed. Supplements like Creatine and protein shakes for body building don't have to be tested by government regulators like the FDA, so excuse me for my lack of trust towards the safety and scientifically proven effectiveness of said supplements. Good day kid.
11-26-2012, 09:08 PM #13
show me one bodybuilder who doesn't take supplements!!!
11-26-2012, 10:14 PM #14
Kai.A
Yippie Kai.A, Mother****er!
Originally posted by Meatwad View Post
Lolkid? Again I'm in college, so most certainly not a kid. And supplements like Creatine occur naturally in the body (because I'm assuming you eat meat) where you are already getting (for the most part) the maximum amount needed. Supplements like Creatine and protein shakes for body building don't have to be tested by government regulators like the FDA, so excuse me for my lack of trust towards the safety and scientifically proven effectiveness of said supplements. Good day kid.

You're not going to make it far if you seek validity from the government when studies have already proved it to be effective.

The following user thanked Kai.A for this useful post:

Xiao Xin
11-26-2012, 10:25 PM #15
Meatwad
Meatman
Originally posted by Konsumer View Post
You're not going to make it far if you seek validity from the government when studies have already proved it to be effective.

So essentially what you are saying is that you are fine with consuming a product that has not been tested by the FDA? What about examples like Cocaine and Coca Cola (which eventually became smaller amounts til eventually none in the recipe?)
11-29-2012, 04:32 AM #16
Kai.A
Yippie Kai.A, Mother****er!
Originally posted by Meatwad View Post
So essentially what you are saying is that you are fine with consuming a product that has not been tested by the FDA? What about examples like Cocaine and Coca Cola (which eventually became smaller amounts til eventually none in the recipe?)

The FDA is nothing. It's been proven already that is helps, I don't need the FDA for something that's already been verified. What about the Coca Cola thing? It has no relevance, cocaine had no significance back then. It helps to speed up the release of endorphins, dopamine, etc. - that's why they used it in the drink - to make it more enjoyable.
11-29-2012, 03:31 PM #17
Meatwad
Meatman
Originally posted by Konsumer View Post
The FDA is nothing. It's been proven already that is helps, I don't need the FDA for something that's already been verified. What about the Coca Cola thing? It has no relevance, cocaine had no significance back then. It helps to speed up the release of endorphins, dopamine, etc. - that's why they used it in the drink - to make it more enjoyable.

The FDA is nothing? What kind of retard are you? I'll say this, Creatine may not be bad for you, but there are other supplements that body builders and such have been using for years and it wasn't until recently scientific bodies and government organizations like the FDA proved them to be dangerous. For example: GHB, GBL, BD, Androstenedione, as well as many supplements with Xtreme in their name. So kid, you know nothing obviously. If it weren't for scientific research and the FDA, people would still be consuming this garbage. But then again, you're fine with cancer I presume?

The following user thanked Meatwad for this useful post:

Camaro
11-29-2012, 07:18 PM #18
Camaro
Chevy Runs Deep
Originally posted by Meatwad View Post
The FDA is nothing? What kind of retard are you? I'll say this, Creatine may not be bad for you, but there are other supplements that body builders and such have been using for years and it wasn't until recently scientific bodies and government organizations like the FDA proved them to be dangerous. For example: GHB, GBL, BD, Androstenedione, as well as many supplements with Xtreme in their name. So kid, you know nothing obviously. If it weren't for scientific research and the FDA, people would still be consuming this garbage. But then again, you're fine with cancer I presume?


He obviously hasn't seen those commercials advertising a new drug as good and safe, but 3 months later another commercial comes out saying "If you or someone you love has used so and so in the past 3 months, and is suffering from this and that, you must take legal action now."

The following user thanked Camaro for this useful post:

Meatwad
11-29-2012, 10:44 PM #19
Meatwad
Meatman
Originally posted by Camaro View Post
He obviously hasn't seen those commercials advertising a new drug as good and safe, but 3 months later another commercial comes out saying "If you or someone you love has used so and so in the past 3 months, and is suffering from this and that, you must take legal action now."

Thank you someone with a brain. It doesn't matter if it's a supplement or not. Any substance has the potential to have negative consequences and without third party research and government organizations like the FDA, we'd all be screwed. It wasn't that long ago when asbestos and lead-based paint was all fine and dandy to use and now we know they are alll cancerous.

The following 2 users say thank you to Meatwad for this useful post:

Camaro, Swifter

Copyright © 2026, NextGenUpdate.
All Rights Reserved.

Gray NextGenUpdate Logo