Originally posted by ALB123
SiNiST3R, do you prefer to drive all of your GT6 cars with ABS turned off? I have always driven my GT6 cars with ABS=1. That is until danbojte, a great guy at GTPlanet, created the Ridox Replica Garage Fan Club. We started racing on Saturday mornings and the official rules insist that everybody drive with ABS=0. I had a really hard time at first, but I have gotten better. I am still much faster with ABS=1, but I totally appreciate the extra "skill" that is required to drive GT6 cars without the assistance of ABS. I have heard different theories on how ABS works in GT6. I would like to hear what your thoughts are regarding ABS in GT6...
I will say, You are asking the right questions.. Hard ones..
Thats a BIG question, no simple answer, very much opinionated and personal,I will give my current position as this one has had me swaying a bit as I tell myself,Im a guy who plays a video game but like to keep it real. as weird as that sounds I understand it, I think some of you guys know what I mean...
Im knocking on 40's door. Im not "old" but a lil older than some of those playing GT6. The older guys will remember a time when at the track the term ABS or TCS never came up, those were things not found on the racing track in any racing. If you got caught using electronic aids you got DQ'ed Im still a lil bit stuck in the past as I appreciate the skill that is involved in driving these high powered cars with no electronic aids. Fully in control, feeling EVERYTHING, there is a communication between driver, vehicle and road that gets blurred the more assist get thrown in.
When it comes to cars from this time absolutely no assist, I see it as sacrilegious, unless we are talking about a retro mod, an Old School car built in modern years with modern tech. Take the Red Devil for example, a First Gen Camaro with everything new school, including ABS. However something like the Lotus 97T should NEVER see ABS or TCS EVER, its IMO just wrong, if the driver cant drive the car without ABS or TCS, they need to practice more with other cars before they try to conquer something like the 97T...
There is still ABS free racing today, like SCCA Spec Miata etc. These restrict the use of ABS. If ABS is SPECIFICALLY restricted then t simply should not be used if recreating that spec (That goes out to ALL the guys racing "Spec" Miatas with ABS-1), using that shit is just WEAK...
Ive had my opinion on this change somewhat.. I used to be ABS Zero or go home. But If I want to act like Im about realism then thats not right. Even some street cars people build up into weekend track warriors like many build plans of cars in GT6 are trying to recreate, these car have ABS IRL and its not getting disabled and cant get simply turned off when these guys are tracking the cars. Guys like Chris Harris when testing cars in factory trim, often have buttons to kill reduce or semi shut off the TCS, but no turn off ABS button, so recreating those laps for example would require the use of ABS IMO. Or look at the new Nismo GTR, I dont think you can ever really FULLY shut off all the computers and run no electronic assist no ABS etc without modifying the car (loosing warranty instantly) but if we want to try to recreate the laps that Motor Trend did for example we would have to drive the car the way he did and in that case that means ABS is on in the least, that one would probably need ASM and TCS to be really real.
So where does that leave me with GT6..
Old cars, the classics. I don't modify, I drive them AS IS from the factory with ABS and TCS shut off. Cars of the 90's ABS was shut off or disabled when we tracked & I personally prefer to drive with ZERO ABS so I do.
HOWEVER cars 2000+ I flop around, it depends on the situation
Its a case by case, car by car race by race situation.
I always go for Zero ABS first but I dont stress over some cars that are just NOT BUILT FOR NO ABS.. We have been getting serious performance edition cars and these cars have practically racing brakes from the factory. If some of these factory brake kits were time traveled back to the 80's they would be better than most Racing Brakes on racing cars. These brake kits dont work properly without ABS In Real Life, because they are designed around ABS, and no way to shut it off. I will use ABS on these cars and I dont feel bad about it, in fact in many of these cases turning ABS OFF would be LESS realistic.
ABS and even TCS are in racing cars, just look at GT3 cars, they run ABS & TCS
You must login or register to view this content.
I will be honest its been something more and more as the years go by. ABS and TCS are sneaking into racing and how can I say Im about keeping it real if I talk shit to somebody in a GT3 car with ABS and TCS when the cars IRL are using it? SO I personally go for ABS Zero Even on GT3 cars, but I got NO PROBLEM racing them online with guys running ABS at 1, I have the option to use it if I think it will make me more competitive, if I still go for no ABS its all on me, I wont cry to the room, about them only beating me because I didn't use ABS, I had it available like everybody else..
I still go for Zero ABS even when racing online. If you look at the video of my GTI, the online racing video you will see I got the standard brakes on and ABS shut off even though the other guys are using ABS, the car is a MKV and it was sold with ABS. We are talking 450pp Golf, its still a game and 450pp even CS I don't need ABS. IN THIS CASE I shut it off.
However running the Red Devil, I have watched the owner running the car and hes got the ABS on it so IMO to recreate the Red Devil as the Real Car, I run it with ABS-1 EVEN THOUGH I don't feel I need it. Note the car is driveable with Zero ABS but the brakes are too grabby and I cant help think, hmmm, well yeah, If I had that brake kit on, with no ABS the brakes would be too damn grabby now wouldn't they. Its more real in this case to use ABS now isn't it.
I will make a note that YES there is the additional Stability Assist found in GT6 ABS thats not in real life, BUT I dont actually think its all too big a deal, at least not as much as I once thought it to be. To me that aspect is of little concern. Im more interested in recreating the realism and often times ABS is needed for more realism, extra bit of assist or not. When it comes to TESTING THE PHYSICS all assist IMO need to be shut off so that we can ELIMINATE the assist as a contributing factor. If you look at the OP, there is a link for a post where I talk on the Problems of using an assist like ABS (with the added stability assist) when TESTING the physics..
I think there is a real value to learning how to drive fully no assist, I think everybody should learn to drive no assist.. I have a lot of respect for Zero Assist Times, much more so than I do for times where ABS is used.
We have new things coming like ERS and torque vectoring. A lil FYI Some Torque Vectoring systems uses the ABS system to torque vector, slightly applying the brakes to the inside wheels transfers more tq to the outside wheels.. These new technologies use more and more electronics to drive the car.I think of it like going from Hydraulics to Fly-By-Wire controls in a fighter jet. Modern Jets are UNSTABLE by design using electronics to translate inputs into outcome. Modern cars are adopting the same philosophy of being naturally unstable BUT a sort of Drive By Wire to translate driver inputs into vehicle outcome. The Unstable vehicle is stabilized by the electronics.
I commend Ridox for his quest for always no ABS, but I disagree with him on the subject. Keeping ABS at zero all the time IS NOT really more real than guys running ABS-1 all the time. It VERY MUCH Depend on the details, going ONLY one way or the other IMO is wrong both ways.